‘In Silence:’ a brilliant breathtaking example of installation art or simply a tangled ball of yarn thrown into a room? By definition, an art installation piece is a three-dimensional visual artwork, often created for a specific-place, and is designed to change the perception of space. Installation art can be done in all types of materials and mediums, including textiles. ‘In Silence’ consists of a burnt piano, black thread being the textile, and depending on where it’s located an audience of chairs (see figs. 1 and 4). It is an installation piece made by Japanese installation artist Chiharu Shiota, an artist whose work with textiles has been known to open the minds of millions. Shiota is a performance and installation artist, whose lived and worked in Berlin since 1996. The images above are all alternative versions of ‘In Silence,’ a piece most intriguing and captivating by it’s tangles of thread wrapping around inanimate objects. However, why is it built in such chaotic way, and can it really be seen as installation art?
Generally, Chiharu Shiota’s artworks arise from personal experiences and emotions, and have shocked people from all over the world. Her work has made her audience question universal concepts, like identity, boundaries, and existence (Mori Art Museum, 2019). Additionally, she has stated that the helpless conflicts of minds, uncommunicable emotions and her inexplicable existence are the things that give her works form and shape (Mori Art Museum, 2019). ‘In Silence’ is one of her more well-known pieces, and like many of her others, is indeed derived from a personal experience. This work was inspired by Shiota’s own traumatic incident as a child, having watched her neighbour’s house burn to the ground. The charred piano is a direct memory of her watching her neighbour’s grand piano blaze up in a smoky mist (Noorata, 2012). The burnt piano covered in black thread symbolises sound, and the absence of it, as it plays visual music (Mori Art Museum, 2019). It is very powerful as Shiota also stated that by seeing the piano burn down she felt as if her own voice had also been burnt (Varenne, s.d). The way the installation is done shows that the visitors can walk through and underneath the fog of black thread in solemn silence, feeling a sense of sadness and loss hangs in the air, as if Shiota has trapped her painful memories in the room (Fieldgate, Wadsworth, s.d). Finally, Shiota stated in an interview that her mindset at the time of creating the installation, shows in the way she stitches the thread: when she’s unsettled and not in a steady mindset the thread is more tangled up and irregular, whilst when she’s in a balanced state of mind the thread comes out a lot more regular and clean (Shiota, 2014). For Shiota the act of weaving is like a form of dance, as if it were meditation, or part of parallel world (WePresentWeTransfer, s.d). From the reasons as to why the piece was made, all the way down the to the construction of it, Shiota truly puts her all into her work, with the way she weaves each thread like their extending out from her body and the object itself.
‘In Silence’ is a temporary large scale art installation piece, that has been installed in many different countries, and many different types of art museums and galleries (Azzarello, 2013). This piece alone has been exhibited in Switzerland, Australia, and Japan, just to name a few (Azzarello, 2013). In Tokyo, Japan ‘In Silence’ (along side many of her other thread installations) was part of Chiharu Shiota’s largest solo exhibition in 2019 at the Mori Art Museum (Mori Art Museum, 2019). Due to the piece’s temporary nature after every exhibition the artist has to take it down, and when asked in an interview about how she felt when doing so, Shiota stated “it’s the course of nature and art work,” (Shiota, 2014). In her opinion what matters is, the emotional impact the installation makes on the audience that way the piece doesn’t really cease to exist instead in lives on in the memories of the people (Shiota, 2014). The importance of scale is visible here as it seems that the audience wouldn’t be able to fully appreciate and experience the installation if it was only small scale, because the magnitude of it allows the visitors to be overwhelmed, and truly effected by it. Shiota prefers to not build models, or visualise the idea behind her work, instead she prefers to turn the piece into a reality during the set up (Shiota, 2014), so there is never a distinctive pattern or shape created in the yarn, and each time she builds the installation it is slightly different. So how does an artist know when their work is complete if they follow no model or pattern? Well Shiota has stated that for her, the piece starts to feel complete when she can no longer see a trace of yarn installation or art object (WePresentWeTransfer, s.d).
The question is, is the black thread really important in the installation or is it just out of place? Although, the destroyed piano and chairs could be quite an interesting statement alone, it’s the thread that truly brings the piece together and makes it so appealing to the audience. These objects are entangled in black thread that is gripping the walls and floors wrapping around the entire room (Azzarello, 2013), but what’s the reason for her using thread/yarn? Shiota’s use of yarn has nothing to do with handicrafts, yarn simply allows her to explore breadth and space like a line in a painting (Shiota, 2015). A thread to her “is an analogy for feelings or human relationships,”(It’s me Ana, 2020). She realised, during her university studies, that two-dimensional painting wasn’t enough anymore, and began exploring the limitless three-dimensional world around her (It’s me Ana, 2020). She describes her line work in yarn as brushstrokes in paintings, but instead of using a brush on canvas she uses yarn in space (Textile Forum Blog, 2019).
Shiota has created an intimate and immersive experience within the neutral exhibition room, as the visitors walk through the room in a direction already “dictated by the delicate net” (Fieldgate, Wadsworth, s.d). She also creates her immersive atmosphere by using everyday objects that the audience would most likely already have a sentimental connection with naturally linking them to the piece. She uses three different thread colours depending on the nature of the installation. Those three colours are as follows, black, white, or red: red thread representing blood, life and vitality, emotions, and human relationships, (Krystals, 2012) white thread is pure, and Shiota has stated that “in Japan the colour is connected to death, it is a blank space, it is timeless” (Shiota, 2019), and black thread can be representing the night sky or cosmos (Gleason, s.d). By knowing that black thread is meant to represent the night sky, it can make the installation seem more eerie, as the visitor can picture a beautiful grand piano burn up in flames in the dead of night. However, the black thread could also be interpreted as representing a swarm of smoke and flames engulfing the piano, and other furniture items, making the audience feel almost trapped in the room watching the destruction that the flames are causing (Noorata, 2012). The black thread completely stretched out over the space can also be seen in a psychological way, trying to physically express the feelings of anxiety and tension. As well as, others may interpret the burnt objects void of function as representing the relationship between one’s self and the outside world, loneliness, and frustration (Asia Art Archive, s.d). The black thread in ‘In Silence’ can mean a multitude of things, and can create all different outlooks for the audience, henceforth it is indeed an important and crucial element in the piece.
Now the question still remains, is ‘In Silence’ a breathtaking and thought-provoking example of installation art, or is it simply a ball of yarn thrown into a room? Well after looking through Chiharu Shiota’s work, it can be seen that she is indeed an artist of unique style. Shiota throws her all into her work, as every piece comes from her personal life, and emotions. ‘In Silence’ is no exception to that, and no matter how many times Shiota has had to take it down and put it back up, she’s always been able to leave the audience in awe, and have the work live on forever in people’s memories. Even though in each place the installation piece has to be different because of the new environment, she has never failed to construct it with all the same elements and create all the same effects. Chiharu Shiota’s work has on countless occasions been able to shock the minds of millions with this exact installation, for this very reason it does seem to be a brilliant example of breathtaking installation art.
Word Count (without bibliography): 1,509
List of References:
Asia Art Archive. (s.d) From In Silence: Chiharu Shiota At: https://aaa.org.hk/en/collection/search/library/from-in-silence-chiharu-shiota (Accessed on: 13/05/2020)
Azzarello, N. (2013) ‘chiharu shiota’s thread wrapped charred piano for art basel’ In: Design Boom {online} At: https://www.designboom.com/art/chiharu-shiotas-thread-wrapped-piano-for-art-basel/ (Accessed on: 15/04/2020)
Fieldgate, K. Wadsworth, J. (s.d) In Silence Perspectives At: https://www.silent-frame.com/articles/in-silence-chiharu-shiota (Accessed on: 17/04/2020)
Gleason, A. (s.d) String Theory: Chiharu Shiota at the Mori Art Museum At: http://www.dnp.co.jp/artscape/eng/ht/1910.html (Accessed on: 14/04/2020)
It’s me, Ana (2020) Chiharu Shiota: A Story of Threads {online blog} In: medium.com At: https://medium.com/@itsmeana/chiharu-shiota-a-story-of-threads-e9478036616d (Accessed on: 13/05/2020)
Krystals, K. (2012) Japanese Colour Meanings At: https://kaliskrystals.wordpress.com/2012/11/19/japanese-colour-meanings/ (Accessed on: 14/05/2020)
Mori Art Museum (2019) Shiota Chiharu: The Soul Trembles; About the Exhibition At: https://www.mori.art.museum/en/exhibitions/shiotachiharu/02/index.html (Accessed on:
15/04/2020)
Mori Art Museum (2019) Shiota Chiharu: The Soul Trembles; About the Artist At: https://www.mori.art.museum/en/exhibitions/shiotachiharu/index.html (Accessed on: 12/04/2020)
Mori Art Museum (2019) Shiota Chiharu: The Soul Trembles; Main Works on Show At: https://www.mori.art.museum/en/exhibitions/shiotachiharu/04/index.html (Accessed on: 12/05/2020)
Noorata, P. (2012) ‘Recreating a Scorched Room with Black Thread’ In: My Modern Met {online} At: https://mymodernmet.com/chiharu-shiota-in-silence/ (Accessed on 16/04/2020)
Shiota, C. (2019) ‘CHIHARU SHIOTA: “THE FEAR IS NECESSARY,”’ Ana Bogdan, The Talk, 03/04, At: https://the-talks.com/interview/chiharu-shiota/ (Accessed on: 17/04/2020)
Shiota, C. (2014) ‘Interview: Chiharu Shiota,’ Marco Giuliano, Impakter, 28/07, At: https://impakter.com/chiharu-shiota/ (Accessed on: 17/04/2020)
Shiota, C. (2015) ‘Stitching the sublime: Chiharu Shiota’s thread of time – interview,’ Art Radar (24/07), At: https://artradarjournal.com/2015/07/24/chiharu-shiota-artist-profile/ (Accessed on: 14/05/2020)
Textile Forum Blog (2019), Chiharu Shiota – Beyond Memory, {online blog} At: https://www.textile-forum-blog.org/2019/05/shiharu-shiota-beyond-memory/# (Accessed on: 13/05/2020)
Varenne, O. (s.d) In Silence At: https://www.detached.com.au/in-silence (Accessed on: 13/05/2020)
WePresentWeTransfer. (s.d) Chihaur Shiota I want them to dig deep into their souls At: https://wepresent.wetransfer.com/story/chiharu-shiota/ (Accessed on: 14/05/2020)
List of Illustrations:
Figure 1. Shiota, C (2008) {Installation Art} In Silence At: https://www.designboom.com/art/chiharu-shiotas-thread-wrapped-piano-for-art-basel/ (Accessed on: 17/04/2020)
Figure 2. Shiota, C (2011) {Installation Art} In Silence At: https://www.designboom.com/art/chiharu-shiotas-thread-wrapped-piano-for-art-basel/ (Accessed on: 17/04/2020)
Figure 3. Shiota, C (2011) {Installation Art} In Silence At: https://www.designboom.com/art/chiharu-shiotas-thread-wrapped-piano-for-art-basel/ (Accessed on: 17/04/2020)
Figure 4. Shiota, C (2018) {Installation Art} In Silence At: https://www.designboom.com/art/chiharu-shiotas-thread-wrapped-piano-for-art-basel/ (Accessed on: 17/04/2020)




























































